Try The Athletic for FREE for 30 days: https://theathletic.com/tifofootball
๐ Tifo’s new book, “How to Watch Football” is now available internationally: https://linktr.ee/tifobook
Everton have been given the heaviest points deduction in Premier League history.
It is a ruling which puts them at serious risk of relegation and itโs a judgement they also intend to appeal.
How did they get here? What have they done wrong? Why are they going to appeal?
Explained by Patrick Boyland and Matt Slater.
Follow Tifo Football:
Twitter: https://twitter.com/TifoFootball_
Facebook: http://facebook.com/TifoFootball
Instagram: http://instagram.com/TifoFootball_
Listen to the Tifo Football podcast:
The Athletic UK: http://bit.ly/TifoPodChannel
Apple Podcasts: http://bit.ly/TifoFootPod
Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/06QIGhqK31Qw1UvfHzRIDA
Watch more Tifo Football: Tactics Explained: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLWYJXDKS21OE39KTymISkCrgCckZh2_sD&playnext=1
Finances & Laws: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLWYJXDKS21OEcOCEjYX59zfcGYrCXFMR2&playnext=1
Tifo Football Podcast: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLWYJXDKS21OHj085qILmy-O2-yZqFIcuM&playnext=1
Most Recent Videos: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLWYJXDKS21OGSHqQmRnREA6J11Tadn1zC&playnext
1 Popular Videos: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLWYJXDKS21OF841IcGORTXynu2l67jpeE&playnext=1
About Tifo Football:
Tifo loves football. We create In-depth tactical, historical and geopolitical breakdowns of the beautiful game.
We know thereโs an appetite for thoughtful, intelligent content. For stuff that makes the complicated simple.
We provide analysis on the Premier League, Champions League, La Liga, Serie A, Bundesliga, World Cup and more.
Our podcasts interview some of the gameโs leading figures. And our editorial covers football with depth and insight.
Founded in 2017 and became a part of The Athletic in 2020. For business inquiries, reach out to tifo@theathletic.com.
Music sourced from epidemicsound.com
Additional footage sourced from freestockfootagearchive.com
#Everton #PremierLeague #EPL
Everton have been given the heaviestย points deduction in Premier League history. It is a ruling which puts themย at serious risk of relegationย ย and itโs a judgement they also intend to appeal. But what have they done and howย have they reached this point?
In the middle of the November, it was announcedย that Everton had been handed a 10-point deductionย ย for breaching the Premier Leagueโs profitabilityย and sustainability rules (PSR). The club wereย ย referred to an independent commission in Marchย for alleged breaches relating to the 2021-22ย ย
Season โ only the second time such action has beenย taken after Manchester City were hit with moreย ย than 100 financial fair play (FFP) charges lastย season โ and a hearing took place over five days. Premier League rules dictate that clubsย can lose up to ยฃ105million ($130.5m) overย ย
A three-year cycle, although certain add-backs,ย including losses caused by the COVID-19 pandemic,ย ย expenditure on infrastructure, community projectsย or womenโs and academy teams are permitted. During last monthโs hearing, the Premierย League argued that Evertonโs cumulativeย ย losses for the FFP cycle ending in 2022ย were, at ยฃ124.5million, ยฃ19.5m over theย ย
Limit. Despite initially denying any wrongdoing,ย Everton eventually accepted they were in breachย ย by a smaller sum of ยฃ9.7m but claimed theyย were entitled to โsubstantial mitigationโ. According to the commissionโs report, Evertonย cited several factors as mitigation, among them:ย โข Their costly stadium project and aย difference of opinion over how loansย ย
To fund the scheme should be accounted for โข The impact of COVID-19, primarily on theirย ย ability to sell in the market โข The unexpected terminationย ย of a key playerโs (โPlayer Xโ)ย contract due to unforeseen eventsย โข Their โtransparentโ cooperationย with the Premier League.
Everton also argued they had been almostย uniquely affected financially by Russiaโsย ย invasion of Ukraine in February last year.ย At short notice, they were forced to suspendย ย sponsorship agreements with companies linkedย to sanctioned oligarch Alisher Usmanov. In their submission, they detailed too howย they had scrapped a stadium naming-rightsย ย
Deal with one of those entities, USM Holdings,ย that was worth up to ยฃ200million over 20 years. Initially lined up to come into effect in 2025,ย ย the club said they had been inย negotiations with USM โ beforeย ย Russiaโs invasion of Ukraine โ to bring theย agreement into force early in 2022 instead.
One of the main bones of contention wasย Evertonโs treatment of loans relating toย ย their new stadium project. In the absence of anย external debt package, they had largely reliedย ย on loans from the clubโs majority shareholder,ย Farhad Moshiri, to fund construction costs forย ย
The ยฃ760million development. Everton Stadiumย Development Ltd was set up as a wholly-ownedย ย subsidiary of the club, but remained entirelyย dependent on inter-company loans from Everton. In Evertonโs 2022 calculations, they said loans toย Everton Stadium Development โbore financing costsย ย
By way of interest and arrangement feesโ. Yet theย commission decided the club had been โless thanย ย frankโ in their submission and considered this toย be an โaggravating factor in their culpabilityโ. Ultimately, the commission and theย Premier League took a different viewย ย on how the club came to breach the regulations.
โEvertonโs understandable desireย to improve its on-pitch performanceย ย led it to take chances with its PSRย position,โ the commission concluded.ย ย โThose chances resulted in it exceedingย the ยฃ105million threshold by ยฃ19.5million.โ It added: โThe position that Everton finds itselfย in is of its own making. The excess over theย ย
Threshold is significant. The consequenceย is that Evertonโs culpability is great. โEvertonโs PSR trend over theย relevant four years is positive,ย ย but we cannot ignore the fact that the failureย to comply with the PSR regime was the resultย ย of Everton irresponsibly taking a chanceย that things would turn out positively.โ
It was also argued that Evertonโs failure toย sell Richarlison for more than ยฃ60million,ย ย ยฃ20m under what they had initially forecast,ย was a key part of their non-compliance. The commission ruled that all the numbersย involved constituted a โseriousโ breach ofย ย
The Premier Leagueโs FFP rules and that anyย punishment should be significant as a result. How have Everton responded? In a statement on Friday 17th November, the clubย said they were โshocked and disappointedโ andย ย described the 10-point deduction as a โwhollyย disproportionate and unjust sporting sanctionโ.
Everton maintain they have acted in good faith,ย regularly liaising with the league over their PSRย ย position. The Premier League placed Everton underย several financial restrictions from the summer ofย ย 2021, including what was effectively an informalย salary cap. All deals, including transfers andย ย
Contracts, had to be approved by league officialsย before they were finalised. The club believeย ย they complied with these measures and that thoseย efforts have not been properly taken into account. Everton have also noted the commissionย did not determine this to be a deliberateย ย
Breach and pointed to the three-manย panel admitting that โthere was noย ย sporting imperative in the circumstancesย (not least when other clubs had, in effect,ย ย been able to capitalise similar capital-relatedย expenditure)โ. As such, the clubโs position isย ย that a sporting sanction, such as a pointsย deduction, is not an appropriate punishment.
There is a feeling, based on the independentย commissionโs use of the word โdeterrentโ,ย ย that they have been unfairly used as a scapegoatย while other clubs go unpunished. Everton haveย ย indicated they will appeal, with an outcomeย expected before the end of the season in May.ย
โEverton maintains it has been open andย transparent in the information it has provided toย ย the Premier League and it has always respected theย integrity of the process,โ reads their statement. โThe club does not recognise the findingย that it failed to act with the utmost goodย ย
Faith. The harshness and severity ofย the sanction imposed by the commissionย ย are neither a fair nor a reasonableย reflection of the evidence submitted. โThe club will also monitor withย great interest the decisions madeย ย in any other cases concerning the Premierย Leagueโs profit and sustainability rules.โ
22 Comments
Dont forget the ban that stopped all prem teams competing in European football for 2 years i think that heavily impacted everton for something we didnt even do
Please create a video on Europes final stand against the modern football. Allsvenskan in Sweden, no VAR, the 51%-rule and an ever rising supporter culture in the stands. Please shown an alternative to where every other country in Europe is headed.
Being a pompey I feel their pain but we had it much worse you won't see a bigger downfall for a premier league side
Tifo can you create a video on which players united can get in case Sancho leaves. With FFP rules and all…
I wonder where Joey Barton fits in …
Thiefs catching thiefs
The BIG difference compared with city is that with Everton, our breaches were unintentional. We overspent, and we were open and upfront about it. ALL of city's breaches quite clearly are intentional maneuvers to cheat and inflate its revenue with dodgy shadow companies created by themselves. If an unintentional breach is -10, an INTENTIONAL breach should mean a much more severe penalty. Of course, that wont happen.
Manchester City by these standards should've been relegated. It's incredible how clubs like these are still standing and still topping the premier league.
Iโm from Canada so I donโt know whatโs going on but the fact that man city did not suffer a point deduction for their financial violations last year is hilarious. It seems like the rules donโt apply to the bigger teams.
Everton would be comfortably 10th after 3 wins in a row without the deduction
Everton were warned repeatedly by the PL, but went on to spend an astonishing ยฃ470M more than they earned over 5 years. For the 3 year period under review, that total was ยฃ371.8M (vs ยฃ105M losses)
These figures will dwarf any breaches by Chelsea or City.
God help City then hahaha
Remember everyone, the Athletic put in a Freedom of Information Act request for communications between the UK embassy in the UAE and the UAE government regarding the charges against Man City, and it was thoroughly denied with the reasoning be it could damage international relations. It sadly is not shocking, and I am sure there are PL workers who are rightfully mad but the call to just sit on their hands might be coming from way above their pay grade. I am no fan of Everton but it really feels like they got the shortest end of the stick possible
Imagine being punished for loosing to much money ๐ญ
Not an Everton fan at all but Sean Dyche has already done something crazy, winning 4 out of 5 matches after punishment.
That's a huge admiration to fans, footballers and coach uniting against the common enemy in face of EPL and making it out of relegation zone.
Russia attacks Ukraine , UK lets ban all Russians. Israel actively cleansing Palestine, also the UK. Well Israel even deserves funding. EVIL PEOPLE
Oil rich nations flexing their political influence by lobbying to target weaker football clubs
dirty stuff. Man City and Chelsea should be sanctioned too
Waiting for City and Chelsea's point deduction…
iranian in a league owned by arabs, not surprised that he's being thrown out
I still canโt accept how Everton had a harsher punishment than Man City. Genuinely
"Financial fair play" rules aka "profit and sustainability" rules aka "the currently top clubs are the most profitable clubs for the league to advertise so we're going to make up rules so they always have a leg up on everyone else" rules aka the "dont you DARE disrupt our cash cow" rules.
Honestly Europeans, you can do better. You've got refs blatantly fixing matches, a league making up rules to keep your local team from even being able to compete and petro states with human rights records about the same as the Khmer Rouge buying up your teams. You've totally lost control. Stop getting worked up in uncontrolled ways and smashing up your own cities over anger at football when you should be smashing up the commissioner's faces. You knew where to find Sepp Blatter every day, and just left him alone to do his bidding, being as crooked as possible plain as day. Eventually the US had to step in and take care of it. Stop being cowards and take the game back already.
I have a hard time believing the legitimacy of any of this as long as Chelsea of the past and Manchester city of the current go unpunished. What Manchester city has done is 20 to 30 times worse than anything that Everton has done that has been listed in this video. Iโm not a salty Everton fan either, I was rooting for their relegation before this came outโฆ Now I just feel bad for them. Itโs not right that they get to be scapegoated Because the Premier league is too scared to punish some of their bigger name clubs, like Manchester city.