Hello & welcome to a new series – Failed Franchises. In this series I’ll look at train companies that have failed at their franchise agreements. Today is perhaps the most recent & infamous example of this – Transpennine Express. Today I’ll go through the history of the Pennines franchise before looking at what led to TPE’s demise with the government stepping in to take over the franchise in May 2023.
As always thank you so much for watching; do consider liking, subscribing & ‘joining’ the channel. Also, please don’t hesitate to leave feedback or corrections below – I am not someone who travels frequently on TPE so I may get things wrong!
Join my channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCcqdWB_q4Q52h26dQcChKsQ/join (Get several different brilliant perks such as access to videos early and a mention in each video, from £2.99/month!)
Or donate to my Ko-Fi for similar perks: https://ko-fi.com/vanmanyo
SUBSCRIBE – https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCcqdWB_q4Q52h26dQcChKsQ
SECOND CHANNEL:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCOx87HEbY4zCXGOcVGPjXwQ
X- https://twitter.com/Vanmanyo1
Discord server link – https://discord.gg/QYpCgBZ
Music: https://www.davidcuttermusic.com/
Ⓒ Vanmanyo
Hello and welcome to a new series failed franchises on this series I’ll be looking at the failures of several train operating companies which have either been stripped of their contract or have been deemed a failure by the industry and passengers alike today is perhaps the most recent and prominent example of
The government stripping a train operating company of its franchise that being transparent Express the history of transparan Express Services goes way back to the 1990s when British rail under the regional Railways brand introduced the brand for its Cross penine services operated by class8 and Loco hold stock under privatization the brand was
Incorporated into the Northern Spirit ARA trains North franchise which included the whole Regional Railways Northeast franchise creating a mega company though is difficult to manage and Run Northern Spirit Incorporated their branding with their class 158 being repainted into a maroon color scheme with a golden n and transparent Express logo ARA trains Northern
Continued to operate the same franchise with the same stock and branding eventually in 2000 the decision was made by the Strategic rail authority to reorganize the regional Railways Northeast franchise ran by a re retrains Northern and the Northwest Regional Railway franchise run by first Northwestern the reorganization would
See all local and commuter Services merged into one Northern franchise with the longer distance Regional and inter city services being made into a dedicated transparent Express franchise the franchise Was Won by first group kolis with the ARA trains Northern and first Northwestern Services being transferred to the newly named first
Transparent Express on February the 1st 2004 the remaining Northern commuter franchise Was Won by Circo Bello and commenced on the same day however our interest lies in the transparan franchise and how it can be classed as a failed Franchise The transfer franchise started relatively small with all services passing through Manchester Picadilly the new first transpan IR company also served Manchester airport with four trains an hour leaders in Huddersfield also with four trains an hour Hur scarra CLE fors middlesbor and Newcastle to the Northeast with one train an hour and in
The north Liverpool with one train an hour and the services split between Barrow and windir giving them one train 2 hours services from Manchester Airport to York were operated on a 24-hour basis we’ll look a little later how the franchise expanded but first let’s look at the original first transpar on
Express operations the original contract for the joint venture was expected to end in 2011 a close for the franchise to end in 2014 and again in 2016 to coincide with the end date of the northern rail franchise at the beginning of the franchise transparent Express operated class 158 and class 175s that
Were on high from a reever trains Wales the main commitment of the original franchise was the replacement of the entire fleet with several dmus being looked at the units needed to be able to reach 100 mph with their acceleration comparable to the class 180s and voyages as well as this air conditioning two
Toilets per vehicle with one suitable for disabled passengers large luggage and bike racks CCTV in first class was desired by the operator in September 2003 first transparent Express announced that Seaman had signed a contract for 56 new dmus to be constructed although this is later reduced down to 51 by the
Strategic rail Authority the units were specifically designed to converse the hilly terrain of the Pen’s route so were built with high power output although this proved unnecessary and led to relatively low efficiency with only a few routs benefiting from The increased power output these new units designated
The class 185s entered service in 2006 and proved incredibly popular with off peak Travelers however they were not deemed to be suitable for Peak services with them becoming highly overcrowded at these times to resolve overcrowding issued First transionic Press least eight class 170s from 2006 from Southwest trains
With a ninth obtained from Central trains shortly after the nine2 car 170s were used on Manchester CLE for Hur and New York services with the three car 185s used across the entire network by 2007 the transplanting route was extended to serve Glasgow and eding replacing virgin cross country with a
New Fleet of electric units desired to run these services for the lines from Liverpool to Scotland being fully electrified in 2013 this in turn led to 10 class free 50- forms being ordered with the first services to Manchester from Scotland running on the 30th of December 2013
This led to the class 185s being relocated to other services strengthening the fleet these 10 4car class 350s proed popular of Travelers however once again overcrowding Contin to be an issue across the franchise this was exacerbated in March 2014 when the government and train owner porterbrook announced that the nine class 170s would
Eventually be transferred to Children Railways and converted to class 168 to strengthen the New Oxford services this was hugely criticized by many MPS and residents such as Diana Johnson MP for H with several debates occurring in 2013 and 2014 regarding the issue the unit cascad was delayed until 20 5 to allow
Tpe to acquire diesel Replacements the last four class 170s left the fleet in 2016 the temporary replacements for the class 170s were found in six class 156s which were hired from norn these 156s were supposed to boost a desperately deprived Northern franchise for services from Blackpool North however the 156s
With first transparent Express didn’t last too long with the franchise being up for grabs by 2014 kis had now split from first group and one wanted to operate the franchise instead with goahead however first group themselves won the new TP franchise and commenced operations in April 2016 dropping the first branding and just
Calling themselves transparent Express following this franchise changeover the6 has returned to Northern with transpan Express now no longer operating to windir Blackpool or Barrow the new transpan Express franchise now operat services to Manchester Sheffield CLE forbs Liverpool Preston Lancaster Glasgow Edinburgh Newcastle Durham middlesbor scarra York h and finally
Leads the branding also got changed featuring a slick new black blue and purple color scheme with their class 350s and 185s receiving a new livery but how did this service his affair and what led to this new TP franchise being deemed a failure just before we get onto why I
Just want to say thank you so much to any of my channel members or previous donators a huge thank you to D bb87 G Patterson Jack Railway secrets and Lilo rail for your donations SL membership if you want to join them you can by pressing the join button next to
The Subscribe button on my channel thank you so much well even prior to the new franchise first transparent Express run some of the busiest trains in the country with most Rush Hour Services being full and standing in 2014 the chief executive of the TP franchise suggested that there is not enough
Diesel rolling stock in the country at Peak over 25% of commuters couldn’t get a seat the new transparan Express franchise had a chronic shortage of Rolling Stock so very quickly into the franchise in 2018 TP announced Project Nova this project was see the company transform into focusing its services on
Inter City Star ones rather than Regional ones however they still intended to serve as a commuter operator perhaps a Flor already in the project the project would would more importantly see fre new fleets into service to replace the class 350s and allow the 185s to receive refurbishment and then
Strengthen other areas of the network TP signed deals for around half a billion pounds with manufacturers CF and Hitachi the Nova Fleet will be subdivided into three new sections imaginatively named Nova 1 Nova 2 and Nova 3 Nova one was actually ordered under the previous franchise and would boost rout capacity
Between Liverpool and Newcastle V York these 19 5c car units would also be bu mode and have a top speed of 125 mph with options for 140 mph operation should the infrastructure ever permit these units were designated class 802s and would be built by Hatachi as part of
Their IET offering the buy mode offering according to tp’s head of new trains Robert Davis would allow for the units to run under the wires for green operations and then on diesel lines where overhead line electrification had not been constructed yet Davis also pointed at the possibility of removing the diesel engines should
Electrification ever be wide enough boosting efficiency by up to 15% the Nova 2s would be 12 fully electric calf class 397s built as part of their civity range these units would be used on the services from Manchester Airport to Scotland and would be the only fully electric Fleet the company had the most
Controversial units would be the Nova freeze these class 68 diesel locomotives and Mark 58 carriages would operate from Manchester and New York to scabra the new Mark 5as built by CF would be the first new carriages in Britain since the mark falls in the 1980s the sets would utilize 14 class 68
Locomotives built by Stadler with 52 Mark 5as utilizing 14 driving trailers to negate the need for runarounds or extra Locos the class 68 had been in service since 2014 and were highly Infamous for their noise levels surely this could couldn’t affect TPU though all of the Nova trains first entered
Service in 2019 but did they help to ensure the franchise would be less overcrowded and more punctual well we all know the answer here is no but why it is no is a bit more interesting by 2020 Co had hit and the operator was given an emergency measures contract until May
2023 after the worst of the pandemic was over TP were instantly hit with Nationwide rail strikes Le to Major staff shortages as tpe tried to ramp up their service to pre-co levels in October 2022 tpe canceled 30% of their services within a week during half term most of these Services being PC coded
Cancellations a pcode cancellation is where the operator cancels the trains but does not show them on the system this is usually used for plan cancellations such as engineering work and allows the operator to cancel Services where them showing is canceled on the passenger system systems which would in turn confuse passengers if
There was engineering work going on tpe were effectively abusing the system to falsely claim that their cancellations were lower than what they actually were the offered for Rail and Road statistics showed that TP reported cancellations of 5.6% and 11.8% in October and November 2022 this is compared to the nearly 20%
Of services that were actually cancelled in the two months these P coded cancellations could be put in the systems the night before so when passengers woke up the next day they would find their service had just disappeared with no way to claim delay repay as the cancellation did not appear
On the industry systems many of these cancellations were to the airport at Manchester with 25% of services to Manchester Airport from September to November 2022 being cancelled or terminated short of the airport this led to a nearly 30% drop in people taking public transport to the airport with Chris Woodroof the airport’s managing
Director toest suggesting it was causing significant cost and inconvenience for passengers Andy Burnham Manchester mayor suggested the loophole was for the interest of the train companies and their profits only claiming the loophole to be outrageous between the 17th and 25th of November a total of 294 TP Services had been canceled the night
Before and many weren’t shown on industry systems 77 of these were on the CLE fors line alone leaving many people on the line without a rail service to Manchester TP suggested the cancellations were due to high levels of train crew sickness and an intensive crew training program which had huge
Backlogs due to covid which didn’t let the company train the staff needed to run the services required going into 2023 things didn’t get much better for the company during the first reporting period of 2023 1,000 tpe trains were at least partially cancelled with tpe still using p coding as a loophole to get
Around staff shortages the official reporting cancellation figure was 5.8 % for March 2023 but this was actually as high as 177% When taking into account pced cancellations however this was still much better than the 25% cancellation rate seen in January 2023 However the fact TP celebrated this decrease
Suggests just how bad it got labor quick to jump on the bandwagon claiming the conservatives were to blame for giving the franchise to First TP in the first place by April 2023 the government was seriously considering removing tp’s franchise Al together suggesting that all options were on the table by May the
Service had not improved with customers slamming tpe for the service becoming less frequent less reliable slower and more expensive it got so bad that many people gave up on tpe using coaches buses Ubers and mainly cars to complete their Journeys with tpe gaining national attention on news networks for its awful
Service eventually the government had enough and to perhaps increase a dft’s reputation and scare of a train operators the tpe franchise was stripped from first and brought under government control on the 28th of May 2023 since the government has taken control of TP there hasn’t been a huge change in
Service although cancellations have been down with most of them now being around 5% and P coding being decreased overcrowding has not decreased and this has been made worse with the Nova 3 class 68 Mark 5 aets being withdrawn from service during the December 2023 timetable the main reason reason for the
Removal of these 12 five car sets is due to noise complaints regarding the class 68 as well as technical issues regarding the mark 5as hence a huge part of tp’s fleet has been withdrawn with Reliance on the class 185s higher than expected leading to huge overcrowding personally I’ve seen this overcrowding firsthand
When I visited Staley bridge last year to ride one of the mark 5 sets before they got withdrawn attempting to return to Manchester I was physically unable to Bor the first Manchester bound service with the guard telling me to take the next one which was also full but at
Least this time I could board TP is still then a pretty bad operator but I think it’s something that will remain the same regardless of who runs it until there is some proper investment the franchise needs more diesel units alth this is something the whole UK needs
Look at the lights of cross country Great Western Railway and Chon for example however the infrastructure needs improving too electrification platform extensions station expansion signaling all things that could and should happen to ensure the north keeps up with the South although the transpan route is currently occurring between Manchester
Huddersfield and Leeds this isn’t happening until at least 2036 with the current infrastructure being Victorian with it basically falling apart so in conclusion then the transpar franchise has always been a very difficult franchise to run we’re first doing a pretty decent job up until the 2020s with the government hopefully being able
To after the elections in 2024 being able to invest in our Railways and tpe can flourish finally becoming a truly good operator rather than a failed franchise thank you very much for watching this first episode in a series that I hope will have five or six
Episodes let me know in the comments who I should focus on next potentially norn or maybe a Rea trains Wales who knows let me know in the comments below do consider liking and subs subcribing if you have enjoyed this episode and also do consider joining my channel for 299
You can get some cool perks such as watching all my videos early as well as getting shout outs in every video thank you ever so much for watching Goodbye
39 Comments
Hi all, hope you enjoy the first TOC in this new series! Do check out some of my other videos; I have done a video on Avanti's failings too if you are interested in that! Do consider liking & subscribing too; and even consider joining the channel along with my other amazing members if you want to 🙂
Also, if your video is stuttering or not running smoothly, drop the quality down to 1080p, as that seemed to help when I watched the video on my less-powerful laptop!
I live in Manchester and I use SailRail to travel home to family in Ireland via Holyhead to Dublin – changing trains from Manchester Piccadilly (platforms 13 & 14) via Chester, Crewe & Lladnuo to Holyhead on TfW & Avanti is a real pain – and I’ve been doing this for 22 years, daytime and overnight, summer & winter – very few direct trains from Manchester to Holyhead to meet ferry check-in and arrivals at Holyhead, with a 4 hour wait at Holyhead on arrival from Ireland to get to Manchester is totally unacceptable – maybe if the Irish government follows EU climate change directives and bans all short-haul flights between Ireland and the U.K. it will force an improvement in the dismal service – another strange thing is with Northern Rail from Manchester Victoria, it does not stop at Parkway (the nearest station to Liverpool Airport) and carries on to Liverpool Lime St – Ferry companies from Liverpool to Dublin only operate from Birkenhead and don’t accept foot passengers on SailRail where they should be operating from Liverpool old port or even the Manchester Ship Canal at Salford Quays (Deansgate Castlefield to Imperial War Museum Metrolink) with smaller foot passenger only vessels, which could also operate further up the Liffey Channel at Dublin as far as the Custom House or O’ Connell Bridge
Crosscountry? They aren't quite as bad as they were a few years ago but they are still not great.
I would think since there isn't enough 66s about and you can't buy them anymore that 68's could do more container work. One did a driver change in WBQ the other week for the first time, I'm hoping its a regular feature now.
SWR is a failed franchise. Ruined everything SWT worked so hard for over 21 years in under 4.
I miss the TPEs to Windermere, so much more comfortable than the Northern.
Is Virgin Rail still a thing? I'm sure that'd be an interesting story to tell.
OLR has made a huge improvement to TPE, sure there is still a big overcrowding issue but the current service is a huge improvement on early 2023 when I would just assume any TPE service up the ECML would be cancelled.
The main problem IMHO with TPE is lack of capacity (besides their crew problems). 5 carriage trains just aren't enough for their Scotland-Manchester routes and the core Manchester-Leeds corridor. I broadly like the 802 Nova trains but they really need to be 8 carriages instead. The only 'quiet' TPE trains I've been on have been the Edinburgh-Berwick/Newcastle ones to East Linton etc. I did quite well out of the £1 seat sale so I won't criticise them too much. A lot of their problems have been due to infrastructure problems around Manchester as well and they've partly rectified that by only running the Saltburn service through 13/14 at Piccadilly to The Airport. The Liverpool to Newcastle service that I travelled on between Manchester and Leeds was bang on time but was rammed by Huddersfield. The TPE train that I travelled on between Leeds and York was also 15 minutes late because it made a weird diversion through Wakefield and I almost missed the LNER connection at York.
Great start to the series! Surely the entire InterCity East Coast franchise in general could be a series within itself
Great video it does remind me a night in Cleethorpes in December 2022 no tpe trains just emr(local service) i thought at the time how bad tpe was they have improved a bit but i still don't really trust them as a train operator.
Being short of rolling-stock is a rubbish excuse but it's been this way for years. TPE like many other operators could have refurbished HST stock as a temporary measure – lets face it from 2018 onwards availability of mk3 stock and power cars would have proven an excellent stand in. The noisy 68 issue was simply not addressed at all. At least people ordering the 197 etc fleets have the ability to put units together to solve overcrowding. TPE could never figure out if it was an all stops service or an express major stops only service. Honestly the crosscountry routes in the north are awful when it comes to speed and fiddling about with layouts to get an extra 10mph does little.
Great Video! TPE customers have really been through it in recent times. Would wonder what would’ve happened if the Nova order was exclusively 802s, in a large order to ensure that all 185s were run as 6 cars long. Would’ve made the crew training problems a lot less of a problem. Reliability could’ve been so much better if Platforms 15 and 16 were built at Piccadilly, and I have no clue why the TRU electrification is going at such a snails pace. Manchester to Leeds needs electrification asap.
I also want to note how Andy Burnham was eager to have a go at TPE for P-Coded cancellations, when Northern (under the OLR) were doing the exact same thing during that time.
Northern Spririt Transpennine had the best livery of all franchises at the time.
I work for Transpennine Express
Having travelled a lot over the years from Liverpool on TPE, I think the franchise is neither one thing or another. I agree with what you say about it trying to be a commuter service and intercity. In the morning peak from Liverpool, it's busy until you get to Manchester, then it's pretty much empty until you get to Huddersfield and it's time for sardines. At Leeds it's empty again. Another oddity is how poor the first class service is in comparison to the journey times and I was once refused a second cup of tea from Liverpool and Newcastle in first class. So make that cuppa and the biscuit last!
A most interesting video! Well done.
Other issues that TPE have is that the infrastructure is not robust. Let's say Newcastle to Liverpool. If anything goes wrong (staff wise or infrastructure) can not terminate at York as no North bay platforms, can't block a through line, same at Leeds and same at Manchester Victoria. So where do you put a train that needs to terminate short… Answer is nowhere. So, cancel it at origin because it's already accommodated. Trains in the north have got longer but the platform space is still the same.
Another issue with TPE issue was the Liverpool – Leeds – Edinburgh service.
TPE were already to go live and chip away at the Leeds – Edinburgh market and undercut the XC service in price.
However just before going live, LNER, government run challenged DFT about the running. DFT sided with LNER so TPE had to run the service as two separate services, but by the time the DFT ruled, the only paths from Newcastle to Edinburgh were behind the freight paths. This destroyed the business case for TPE and had to adapt quickly.
Great video on a very sad and 25-year long political-economic grift. Transport has never been easy to profit from, but the franchise model is financialisation on steroids.
When we (gov’t by law) split ownership (very rentable) from the company running trains they lease, on infrastructure they also rent – the money spent by passengers go right through to the owners of all the stuff. Not the “users” with tickets or staff.
As everyone looking at property or financial assets knows – that’s the part of “the economy” that actually works. Franchise in debt, expenditures converted to capital in a different company – not into transport itself…
Before Thatcher (and Nixon) this scheme was illegal. Today it has been fully legal for decades. And we don’t see the connections to us (people) losing grip…? 😅
Bring back 125s
RIP Nova 3 😥
Great vid! How about connex south eastern/central
High speed 2s fault
I love this series, Please continue!
BR should never have been privatised. It was run by railwaymen who knew what they were doing but just lacked sufficient funding to be able to run it properly.
Hey man! Great video, really interesting. Quick tip though, make sure your editing in a frame rate that matches your b-roll footage of the trains. At the minute the b-roll looks a bit laggy and stuttery as I presume it is shot at a different frame rate to the frame rate of your editing project. I'd recommend editing and shooting in 30fps, but anything will work as long its consistent. 🙂
THEY NEED 10 COACHES ON NEWCASTLE TO LIVERPOOL SERVICE I WENT FROM YORK TO LIVERPOOL AND IT WAS SO CROWED
I used to go back and forth from Durham to Manchester and Liverpool on the Northern TPE back in the late 90's…
I love travelling on trains, but hated having to goto Liverpool as it used to take ages
nova3 aka the 68 and stock lasted to december2023 were the 68s got returned to DRS stock shoved into storage i think
08:50 – It was Robin Davis, not Robert
I still think that Transpennine Express should improve their services because they have struggled a bit despite they have ordered new rolling stocks and are no longer using the Nova 3 Class 68+Mk5s. Which have now gone for storage.
Being a wheelchair user, the amount of time TPE had to get a taxi from Doncaster to Cleethorpes it was getting ridiculous with all their cancellations
On the subject of TPE The Pennine routes especially in The 80's was far worse in terms of infrastructure but here's a rather unusual story about the trains there. The Class 124 sets were built in 1960 at Swindon for Trans Pennine services. Originally of six car sets of which four of the six car were powered and they also included a buffet car but were reduced to five car and then to four car. All Powered cars had the 230hp Leyland Albion engines and towards the late 70's some were merged with ex BR Western Region Class 123's and against the role of play both classes were withdrawn in 1984 in favour of Loco-Hauled Stock hence the unusual story mentioned. Though The North Yorkshire Moors Railway had the idea of preserving one unit due to the panoramic windows but this was not proceeded with due to the prohibitive cost of removing the asbestos on the set.
TPE are absolutely the worst operator I have ever travelled with… I’ve had issues nearly every time with them and up until recently they were the only choice to travel from Hull to Leeds directly which is a trip I make regularly however Northern thankfully operate the same route now albeit on a slower stopping service, regardless of that I actively avoid TPE now as although Northern aren’t perfect they’re a million times better than the aforementioned excuse of a TOC
In a world of arcane 'parliamentary services' it is particularly galling that a company like TPE failed through having too many passengers! The reach of de-nationalisation is as long as it is insidious.
12:10 Um, I'm pretty sure you're supposed to be at the FRONT when you're driving the train.
Very interesting stuff mate, super interesting on how TPE was pretty troubled at this time, you've just earned another sub!
TPE should have ordered more 802s. With GWR they should have ordered more 9 car sets and not the poor 5 car sets which the DFT forced.