Many of us forget about this detail in our bike fit but could making a small change to our pedal stance width make a big difference to our riding? What is Q Factor and are we overlooking it? We’re here to explain all.
Welcome 0:00
What is Q Factor? 0:11
Scientific studies 1:28
Pro peloton 2:35
Using a narrow Q Factor 2:50
Speaking to the professionals 3:31
Should we worry about our fit? 5:04
Main reasons we get it wrong 5:49
How do I know if I need to change? 8:21
Making changes to my bike fit 10:28
Useful Links:
Everything Cycling. All In One Place 👉 https://www.globalcyclingnetwork.com
GCN Uploader 👉 https://gcn.eu/gcnuploader
Visit the GCN Shop 👉 https://gcn.eu/gcnshop
Watch more on GCN…
📹 Does Rim Width Make A Difference? 👉 https://youtu.be/WzGl48lGllw
📹 Watch our Editor’s Choice Playlist 👉 https://gcn.eu/editorschoice
📹 Or why not check out our Features Playlist 👉 https://gcn.eu/gcnfeatures
🎵 Music – licensed by Epidemic Sound 🎵
Cellar Clefs – Dusty Decks
Malibu Crush – Dylan Sitts
Norita – Jobii
Slide N Glide – Rebecca Mardal
fly on up – Gregory David
Lofi on the Bass – Daniel Fridell
#gcn #cycling #roadcycling #roadbike #bike #bikes #bikelife
📸 Photos – © Velo Collection (TDW) / Getty Images & © Sirotti Images
The Global Cycling Network (GCN) is the largest online cycling channel in the world, bringing together a global community of road cyclists to celebrate everything that’s great about the world of cycling.
Our videos bring fans compelling daily content including expert tutorials, techniques, training, racing, cutting-edge bike tech, unparalleled behind the scenes event coverage, humour, entertainment, and more.
Presented by ex-pro riders, GCN offers a uniquely qualified insight into the world of cycling, and most importantly it’s fuelled by our passionate and enthusiastic fans – everyone who makes up the GCN community. We also bring the latest and greatest tech to your attention, showcase the best places in the world to ride and get exclusive access to events and races.
Welcome to the Global Cycling Network | Inside Cycling
Thanks to our sponsors:
Pinarello Bikes: https://gcn.eu/Pinarello
Topeak Tools: http://gcn.eu/Topeak
Canyon Bikes: http://gcn.eu/-Canyon
Camelbak: https://gcn.eu/Camelbak
Pirelli Tyres: https://gcn.eu/Pirelli
Orbea Bikes: http://gcn.eu/Orbea
Vision Wheels: http://gcn.eu/Vision
Wahoo Fitness: http://gcn.eu/Wahoo-Fitness
Park Tool: http://gcn.eu/-parktool
Whoop Fitness: https://gcn.eu/Whoop
Selle Italia: https://gcn.eu/SelleItalia
SiS: https://gcn.eu/ScienceInSport
Zwift: https://gcn.eu/Zwift
DMT Shoes: https://gcn.eu/DMT
Silca: https://gcn.eu/Silca
MET Helmets: https://gcn.eu/methelmets
Strava: https://gcn.eu/strava
ShadowStand: https://gcn.eu/ShadowStand
Precision Fuel & Hydration: https://gcn.eu/precisionhydration
AGU: https://gcn.eu/AGUxGCN
Elitewheels: https://gcn.eu/Elitewheels
Watch our sister channels:
GCN Tech – https://www.youtube.com/@gcntech
GCN Racing – https://www.youtube.com/@gcnracing
Global Triathlon Network – https://www.youtube.com/@gtn
GCN Italia – https://www.youtube.com/@gcnitalia
GCN en Español – https://www.youtube.com/@gcnenespanol
GCN auf Deutsch – https://www.youtube.com/@gcnaufdeutsch
GCN en Français – https://www.youtube.com/@gcnenfrancais
GCN Training – https://www.youtube.com/@gcntraining
Global Mountain Bike Network – https://youtube.com/@gmbn
GMBN Racing – https://youtube.com/@gmbnracing
GMBN Tech – https://www.youtube.com/@gmbntech
Electric Mountain Bike Network – https://www.youtube.com/@embn
Many of us forget about this detail in our bike fit but could making a small change here make a big difference to our riding we’re talking Q factor Q factor is the lateral distance from the outside of one crank to the other typically this is somewhere
Between 150 to 170 mm depending on the group set you’re using stance width is another term related to Q factor this is instead the distance between your feet when actually on the pedals the Q factor on your bike will of course impact your stance with but the latter is much
Easier to change you can switch out your pedals to ones with different length spindles you can use spacers to change your stance with or you can adapt your cleat position on your shoes all of which can easily change your stance with on the bike recently I switched to these
Longer spindle pedals from Woo which are considerably longer than what I was using in the past and actually a tad longer than what I used back when I was racing as soon as I switched to them I noticed an instant difference in both my comfort and my power transfer and it led
Me to think that maybe I’ve been totally underestimating Q Factor’s ability to change my feeling when I was riding and my ability to ride harder than I thought possible and it made me think maybe we’re all underestimating Q factor in our riding so I’ve decided to dig a
Little Deeper on the topic starting off with any scientific research that’s out there and actually I found very little scientific research out there on the topic of Q factors but I did find one study of note from 2014 out of the University of Birmingham now in this study researchers looked at different Q
Factors and how that impacted mechanical efficiency and the results were quite interesting actually because they found that narrow Q facts actually improved the mechanical efficiency of riders in the study now they did take Q factor as properly defined for this purpose so they swapped out the bottom bracket to
Make it narrower as the study progressed stance width will of course have changed as a result of narrowing that Q factor but it’s interesting because this study it just looked at one single steady state effort it didn’t look at the fact that your power is going to change at
Different intensity levels or your ability to put down the power at those intensity levels nor did it look at Comfort over longer durations of time or how fatigue at that Q factor may impact your ability to put down the power so whilst the conclusions were interesting
It isn’t the whole story and when you look to the pro pelaton there’s actually some really good examples of riders using much wider pedals to their advantage likes of Bradley Wiggins Mark cenes have both been known to go for a longer spindle on their pedals and
Didn’t do them any harm in the power Department another reason given for using a Nar Q factor and stance with is aerodynamics the reason here is the fact that if you do bring your feet close cler to the bottom bracket you bring your legs in out of the wind creating a
Much narrower profile to cut through the air hopefully ride faster as a result now gram OB is a good example of someone who’s done this in the past riding a really narrow Q factor in his Pursuits of the hour record and I get the reasoning here bring your legs in making
Yourself much narrower much lower profile potentially you’re going to cut through the wind better ride faster but at the same time it doesn’t make though if you bring your feet in and you hope to bring your legs in but at the same time you can’t ride in that position
Your knees spray out and you negate any aerodynamic benefit as a result plus it might not be that comfortable over longer periods and whilst we all love to be aerodynamic I think my main priority is being comfortable on the bike and how that transfers to the power in the leg
Department my own personal view is that for all the different Siz bike riders out there there just isn’t the same Choice when it comes to your Q factor when when you compare it to say differen sized Road frames stem length handlebar width even it’s just not the same choice
So I got in touch with bike fitter Phil Bert who has once been previous physio to team sky and British cycling to get his take on the topic and I started by asking him where this kind of standard length for stance width originated from stance width or Q factor the distance
Between our pedals um is fairly standardized you can obviously get longer and shorter on on certain types of pedals but the yeah it’s just standard it’s just a universal thing and I I imagine it’s come from when bikes were first made and commercially made they probably somebody
Arrived on a distance that seemed to work for most people and they probably didn’t want to offer lots of different ones for commercial production reasons and that was decided upon and generally accepted well generally find that and then as we all know we’ in cycling quite often though we have these cultural
Things that we accept as norms and then they stay and they’re very hard to shift um so the honest answer is I don’t know where he come from but he obviously came from somewhere so then stance width and pedal size is pretty generic across the board but should we be concerned with
This according to Phil should we worry about this aspect of our bike fit I think Stanford is massively overlooked as a factor in so many people’s suboptimal setup um it’s not as powerful as some things for example crank satle heik they’re really really important and so on so but you’re right you think
About the the my the variant of handbar positions we have in whips available which takes a fact that you know I’m bigger and wider than someone than maybe a small lady you know um but the stance width is exactly the same it’s just it’s just mental you know and it can cause it
Can be cause problems and it can be the solution for lots of issues for some people you know my hunch is right then and stance withd can have a big effect on your riding but what are the main perils according to the experts expert of getting this part of your bike fit
Wrong with the St the biggest group of people who suffer that are people who have wide hips which are predominantly women the reason for that is people they have wide hips they basically if they’re forced to have a narrow stance withd that’s the thing that affects Q angle Q
Angle is different to Q factor I tend to talk about Q angle and stance with so people don’t get confused um so Q angle is the angle that your quadriceps meets your patella and Patell tender that so you know what the angle the knee comes
Into to and out so you can imagine it’s basically a kin if we if you imagine doing a single leg squat you set up for that with your foot underneath your hip and your knee in line don’t you yeah otherwise you’d fall over yeah if you
Think about it in cycling if you’ve got wide hip you and your foot’s inside that imagine how sub optimal that is biomechanically now you can do it because you’re not going to fall over because you’re sitting on the Pike yeah but it can cause lots and lots of issues
The prime one would be um sort of the knee irritation you know so contribut a medial side knee pain that’s the inside of your KNE or ilot tual band friction with some people it’s really big um more more importantly it you know we if we
Put if we took you now Conor and put you on a leg press machine I said like put your foot all the way in here nearly across your left foot across where your right B would be you wouldn’t be as powerful if you put that foot directly
In line with your hip so yeah I think there’s performance issues there and then there’s pain and suffering issues but stand withd also is important to how you sit on the saddle because if you’re forced to have this very narrow saddling p stance compared to where your hips
Want to be that can be a real common cause for chafing so when people get chafing saddle injuries are bilateral um I regularly change stli and get rid of all someone’s saddle pain which is a bit blows your mind doesn’t it you know um but I think a lot of people end up
Manipulating crank length because they start to have these problems such as and I don’t I know you’ve changed recently but some of us like to walk differently so for example some of us are pitching toad an narrow St withp isn’t going to really but worry those people because
The heels are out but if you’re a duck and you use speed play pedals because you want to drop your feet in remember we walk on bikes we don’t really pedal so your walking mechanism comes onto the bike you can’t drop your healing because the stance would quite now that’s when
You get crank C so people end up adapting to wider pedal systems to not get crank rod but that’s probably what they should have been in the first place how can you tell then if St with is something you need to change and what are the telltale signs in this area you
Need to switch things up I think if you get excessive crank rub um that’s either because you’re on the wrong pedal system got your clean setup wrong but it it quite often will be you’re trying to drop your heal in because and you can’t because the stance whe is too now so
Crank one with one of them I think uh the other thing I mentioned there is if you if you suffer with chafing on the saddle no matter what type of Saddle youd use or that’s a probably a sign that you’re trying to get your legs in here you You’ be internally rotating
Your hip and that’ll be making you sit in a sit in a very sort of narrow um perching point so those sort of things I think also just um the feeling that um I think some people to div into a bit of physio therapy and people either stand
Up straight up and down or have what we call knock knees you know your knees come together or have what we call Bow knees you bit like more like a cowboy or a horse rider yeah but by mechanically you can’t choose that but if you’re bony quite often you’ll benefit from um a
Wider s because it just accommodates the movement of the leg and allows you to get that foot more in line with the hip um so recognizing your biomechanical differences I know that might be hard for someone but if someone recognizes that they’ve been they they have very
Wide apart n is the way they stand it might be that stance withth in in playing around with st and the other thing is it doesn’t take masses you I know speed pay still do one 65s and that but um I often start with a three mil
Increase and the thing is I have had lots of clients in when we start with most pedals will guarantee the thread on the pedal up to um four mil washers and so four mil you can put two two M washes on and move the pedal slightly wider of course you got
Some movement with most of the CLE systems as well um but um you can make big differences with small ones and then you have the horrible pedal extenders which are you know up to 20 mil they look pretty agricultural but they they can if you want to understand what why
They crank with they’re not that expensive you put them on and if you you saw you know you’re much more comfortable more powerful then maybe that’s for you starts with the Q factor then play a vital role in your feeling on the bike and if you are looking to
Change it up yourself what’s the best way to go about it well here are a few helpful tips which should get you on the road changing your cleat position on your shoes is perhaps the easiest starting place if you do want to change your stance with now this is achieved by
Simply moving your cleats either in or out on your shoes you can also add spaces to your existing pedals but remember to just use two Max per pedal for safety reason seasons and this is of course the easiest place to start the cheapest way as well with the least faf
But if you do want a bigger change that is when it’s time to start thinking about swapping your pedals measured from the shoulder of the pedal axle to the center of the pedal pedal Brands come in at around 52 53 mil for their standard length offering Shimano and Wahoo offer
Longer options at 56 mil whilst woo also has two further offerings 59 and 65 mil terms of gravel riding if you’re looking for more of an off-road mountain bike style clipless pedal then Crank Brothers have two different offerings from 52 to 57 mil Shimano spd go from 52 to around
55 mil and I actually came across SQ Labs pedals which have four different pedal lengths from a very short to quite a very long pedal all the way to 69 mm down from around 50 mm so good options on either end of the spectrum if you’re looking to adapt your position both on
The road and Offroad too it’s an interesting one because I think mountain bikes they naturally have a larger Q factor so your STS with is already going to be quite wide so perhaps there isn’t the need to have a longer spindle on your pedal but that is a good point as
Well because if you are switching between bikes going from a mountain bike to a road bike then it is worth knowing the Q factor of both bikes if you can try and keep them relatively similar by adapting your pedal length it’s going to help your riding as you switch between
The two bikes personally though I found that going to wider pedals has really helped my riding I found it really useful and beneficial so it’s definitely something I’m going to keep an eye on as I switch between bikes and try and get that similar position on my road and my
Gravel setups but if you are looking to make some changes do remember the old adage of making small changes over time not making one big lump of a thing that you’re going to have to struggle to adapt to just do those gradual changes see how they feel before you then go and
Make any further adjustments starts with Q factor then something that can make a really big difference to your riding I’ve been guilty of overlooking it in the past and perhaps we all have from time to time but it is something that you should pay attention to and I hope
This video has helped you get a bit more information on the topic and perhaps make a decision about whether you need to make any changes yourself let us know in the comments section below if you’ve experimented with it in the past and what difference it’s made to your own
Writing and if you did find this video useful please give it a big thumbs up thanks for watching as always we see you on the next one
33 Comments
Have you changed your bikes Q factor? 🚲
I think hip width and knee biomechanics are thr determining factors for this
😊
First noticed the difference when I borrowed a set of Assioma power meter pedals from a friend. The extra width felt freer and initially comfortable. When I returned them, normal width pedals felt strange and tight again, maybe as I undid some adaptation. I use 16mm extenders on each side now, and have tried to tweak my cleat width – I feel I'm pedalling more perpendicular, generally feel comfortable, but I think I've had knee pain crop up in either width. My current bike has a wider top tube, so the extenders also help keep my knees clear.
In terms of making small changes, sometimes big changes can help you understand your issues more easily. For example, if you change your seat height so that it's too short, you can feel what too short feels like. If you then change it to be too high, you can feel what that feels like. You know that the proper height is somewhere in between. At that point you can start moving slowly in one direction until you just feels like it's about right. Then move all the way to the other extreme and move the other direction slowly until it just feels like it's about right. The two "just about right" points will still probably have some space between them. You can then move the saddle height smack dab in the middle of that knowing that you are in a "goldilocks" position with a little bit of room to spare on either side.
I added a pedal washer on each side as a result of my bike fit (thanks Fraser Bike, Michigan)re knee arthritis issues, it was like someone turned the lights on
What about foot position for squats and deadlifts? We could probably move on from this topic. Extenders are useful for foot/chainstay clearance.
7:35 "Look at your feet stance, it's so horrifying that I had to point out!"
Very interesting and well researched video. Thanks Conor. I wonder why there are no asymmetrical/offset cleats to change your stance. Would be the cheapest option and a good way to experiment.
I wonder if riders like Tom Pidcock who do road and MTB try to match the stance on all bikes.
Phil Burt may have a lot of experience but he's very difficult to listen to. Not as clear delivery as your usual hosts.
Edit: "(Pedal extenders) look pretty agricultural" what even is that
I see a few caveats, too narrow and your thighs can rub against the saddle, your foot may rotate at an angle where you increase the pressure on the outside of your foot.
Thanks for the info
What effect does Q factor have on the knees "waving" in and out as you pedal? Particularly on harder efforts?
Wow! Amazingly helpful and insightful video Conor and GCN! We'll have to call Conor Science Si soon! Thanks for the deep dive into such a sadly overlooked topic!!! As a retired RMT, having worked in a Sports Injury Clinic, I can attest to the number of people (particularly women triathletes) who have suffered unnecessarily due to the Q factor problem. As Phil said it usually shows in ITB syndrome and knee pain, especially with Ultra Endurance riders. The pedal shaft/spacer hacks are a great work around for some. So too are something you didn't mention: switching to flats. This allows people who have discordant hemi pelvises (a surprisingly large part of the population have one half pelvis larger than the other) to move one foot in more for the narrower pelvis half and the other out more for the wider pelvis half. Flats also help those with rotated tibia (lower leg bone below the knee). When standing with knee caps aligned forward these people will have one "duck foot" toed out due not to muscle stance, but BONE. You can't fight bone! These people need to have ability to toe out on one side and flats accomodate this, so that their knees can stay aligned/stress free. Bike makers who target bikes designed for women/wider hipped/pelvis people, should be at least moving to a wider Q factor according to averages and then marketing a bike that "just feels right" for women. It would do a lot towards inclusion in the sport. Stellar content and please more of this type of thoughtful video!!! Well done!
I came to this about a year ago when I was now coming back from a broken knee. Was riding MTB flats which let me move my foot position out, then once things were good enough and I wanted to go back to clipless, the standard Q-Factor felt horribly narrow and put pressure on my hips. Bought a set of 20mm extenders and that put my SPDs to just a bit wider than where my feet were on the wider flats. As said, if you've got wider bars for bigger riders, you should also have wider Q-Factor for wider hips.
I’ve run 59cm spindles +1mm washers for many years. When I switched to the wahoo brand, they whack you $50 extra dollars just for the extra 6mm in width. I use some of the additional width to keep the cleats in a reasonable position on shoe, instead of pushing them in to their most extreme position. I also recommend the stainless steel cleat panels to protect the cleat baseplates. Also, if you’re a shorter under 5ft7in, definitely consider running shorter cranks. I’ve gone to 165mm and it’s the best change I’ve made.
Connor, don’t you think your seat is in a little too forward of a position? If that’s where you need to sit, maybe you’re on too big of a frame or need one with a shorter top tube. It also doesn’t look very cool so far forward on the seat tube.
The more videos I see re bike fit the more I'm thinking all bikes should be custom frames. Cheap semi-custom frames would be a hit.
Have the older Campy narrow crankset- more efficient for sure. As for my occasional knee pain- seems more related to my cashier's job and my age.
On my MTB with flat pedals, I noticed that I tend to not use the spikes on the inside when standing. Recently, I got a bike fit on my road bike, and my fitter put my cleats almost all the way in, which may be due to me simply coming from MTB and being used to wider BBs. I am 180cm, mostly legs.
i ride my new roadbike today the first time and i think about to use pedal spacers or extenders
Humans have O and X legs, different width hips and so the Q factor must vary as well. Graeme Obree with his average height and willpower for extreme innovation riding a very narrow Q shouldn't surprise anyone. Good thing the UCI didn't look at his Q back then, otherwise they might have introduced a minimum 😉
Hip width etc bike were standardised. It's an obvious thing really, I'm more Comfortable on a,mountain bike even when I was racing. Issue is MONEY! The companies are charging for it instead of trickle down. Give them some pain guys eh. Speed play , dura ace your talking cash
the Q factor is only in james bond movies.
keywin are the best pedals in the world
I run Garmin Rally XC200 power pedals (SPD). The Garmin Connect report is listing Platform Center Offest (PCO) as 10mm to the outside of each pedal's centerline. Does this mean I should move my cleats out towards my little toe? There isn't 10mm of adjustment. Or do I need longer spindles to move the pedals away from the bottom bracket and under my power point? I keep my pedal clips set to the minimum adjustment.
#servicecomment
'Q-factors' (incorrect, distance from crank to pedal center) of several common pedal systems:
– Shimano SPD-SL 52mm
(w/ Ultegra & Dura Ace +4mm options)
– Shimano SPD 55mm
(w/ XTR -3mm)
– Look Keo/X-Track 53mm
(2mm official Look spacers available)
– Time Xpresso 53mm
– Time Atac 54mm
– Speedplay 50/56/59/65mm available
– Crankbrothers 52mm Standard (Eggbeaters & Candy), Long Spindle 57mm (Mallet Trail, Enduro, etc.)
Who cares about performance. This should be about comfort and overall health of our knees and legs and posture. So it doesn't matter even if Q-Factor reduces performance, it should be about comfort and knee health.
Thank you for this! I've been trying to get my wife's bike to fit her better and reduce the knee pain she's been experiencing, even on shorter 30-45 minute rides. I couldn't think of anything else to try and correct but then your video came along. I realized I'd completely forgotten about the Q-factor. I ordered some pedal extenders and snuck them on her bike for a blind test. It was FTP test day on Zwift and she remarked how this was the first test she didn't have knee pain and also had an 8% improvement in watts!
I used to make my stance wider by using a triple bottom bracket until the bike industry decided that cranks and spindles should be integrated.
Fresh off a bike fit (last week) and one of the adjustments was to widen my stance by 4mm total. This seemingly small change had a great effect on comfort and rippled throughout several measurements bringing my feet more in line where they should be. If your bike fitter isn't looking at that, consider finding one who does. HUGE difference for me.
The pedal spacing on my Tern eCargo bike is almost 2 inches wider than my other bikes and it bothers my hips. I can’t move the SPD cleats more than a couple millimeters so that doesn’t help. Tried flat pedals, toe clips and SPD pedals. Flat pedals were the most uncomfortable. Any ideas?