Hi, and thanks for watching! Join us as we delve into the life of Erich von Manstein, one of the most greatest German Field Marshals of World War II.
This video explores his rise in Hitler’s regime, his fall from grace, and his subsequent arrest and trial. We investigate his controversial role during the war, his relationship with the key figures of the Third Reich, and his perspective on the atrocities committed. We also discuss his role in post-war Germany, including his influence on the Bundeswehr and his best-selling memoir, “Verlorene Siege” (“Lost Victories”). Like, subscribe, and hit the notification bell for more fascinating insights from History Inside
📺 Watch the entire video for more information!
ALSO WATCH:
🔔 Subscribe now with all notifications on for more World War 2 videos👇
https://bit.ly/SubscribeToHistoryInside
_________________________________________________________________
About History Inside:
🎥 Videos with the focus on World War 2
🎨 Written and produced by History Inside
📣 Voice-over by benjaminsvoice.com
🔔 Subscribe to our channel for more videos
_____________________________________________________
❓ Copyright Questions
• If you have any copyright questions or issues please feel free to contact us.
⚠️ Copyright Disclaimers
• We use images and content in accordance with the YouTube Fair Use copyright guidelines
• Section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Act states: “Notwithstanding the provisions of sections 106 and 106A, the fair use of a copyrighted work, including such use by reproduction in copies or phonorecords or by any other means specified by that section, for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching (including multiple copies for classroom use), scholarship, or research, is not an infringement of copyright.”
• This video could contain certain copyrighted video clips, pictures, or photographs that were not specifically authorized to be used by the copyright holder(s), but which we believe in good faith are protected by federal law and the fair use doctrine for one or more of the reasons noted above.
#ww2 #worldwar2 #historyinside
In military history, few figures stand out as brilliantly as Erich von Manstein. A master strategist and a tactical genius, Von Manstein’s name is synonymous with innovation and cunning tactics on the battlefield. Join us as we delve into the life and legacy of this enigmatic
Military commander who left an indelible mark on World War II. From his early days in the German army to his pivotal role in some of the war’s most iconic battles. Let’s get started. Erich von Manstein was born as Fritz Erich Georg Eduard von Lewinski in Berlin on November 24,
1887, into an aristocratic family with a long tradition of military service. His father, General Eduard von Lewinski, was a senior Prussian Army officer and his mother came from a family of prominent politicians. Due to his family’s background, it was expected that von Von Manstein would follow in their footsteps and join the military.
At the age of 18, he joined the cadet corps at Lichterfelde near Berlin and later attended the Prussian Military Academy. He graduated in 1906 and was commissioned as a lieutenant in the 3rd Foot Guards Regiment. During World War I, Von Manstein served on both the Eastern
And Western fronts, rising through the ranks to become a captain by the end of the war. After Germany’s defeat in World War I, Von Manstein remained in the military and was promoted to the rank of major in 1927. He continued to climb the ranks and
Eventually became a colonel in 1932. It was during this time that he began to develop his innovative military strategies, which would later become his trademark. On the 1st of July 1935 Von Manstein was appointed as the Head of the Operations
Branch of the Army General Staff. He would play a central role in the development of Fall Rot (Case Red). This strategic plan was designed to safeguard Germany from potential French attacks. During this time, Von Manstein interacted with Heinz Guderian and Oswald Lutz, both strong advocates for a significant warfare transformation, with a focus
On the Panzer’s role. Despite the push for change, some officers, such as Ludwig Beck, the Chief of the Army General Staff, opposed such drastic shifts. As a result, Von Manstein proposed an alternative solution: the creation of Sturmgeschütze or self-propelled
Assault guns that would offer robust direct-fire support for the infantry. These StuG units proved to be among the most effective and economical weapons in the German arsenal during World War II Von Manstein’s contributions before and during the Blitzkrieg were instrumental in shaping the course
Of the conflict and underlined the effectiveness of this innovative military doctrine. Before delving into Von Manstein’s role in the Blitzkrieg, it is essential to understand the context in which this style of warfare emerged. The term “Blitzkrieg” refers to a fast and overwhelming military offensive characterized by surprise,
Speed, and the use of combined arms – infantry, armor, and air support. Von Manstein’s involvement with Blitzkrieg began well before the outbreak of World War II. Von Manstein, along with other military thinkers such as Heinz Guderian and Walther von Brauchitsch, were instrumental in developing the doctrine of Blitzkrieg. Their ideas focused on mobility,
Combined arms warfare, and surprise attacks to achieve rapid breakthroughs in enemy lines. Von Manstein’s theories formed the backbone of this new doctrine, and his influence on the German military was substantial. As World War II erupted, Von Manstein’s theories were put into practice on a grand
Scale. He was given the command of the 18th Panzer Division. His leadership and innovative tactics were evident during the invasion of Poland in 1939. The 18th Panzer Division played a crucial role in the rapid encirclement and defeat of Polish forces, showcasing the effectiveness of Blitzkrieg tactics.
Von Manstein’s unit, demonstrated the importance of well-coordinated mechanized forces and close air support. One of Von Manstein’s most famous achievements occurred during the Battle of France in 1940. He commanded the German forces that launched a daring attack through the Ardennes Forest, a route considered impassable for large,
Armored formations. This audacious move surprised and outflanked the French and British defenders, leading to the quick fall of France. Von Manstein’s tactics at the Battle of France highlighted the mobility and audacity that characterized Blitzkrieg warfare. Von Manstein’s contributions extended beyond the early victories of the war. He played a key role
In the planning and execution of Operation Barbarossa, the invasion of the Soviet Union in 1941. His strategies, particularly in the battles around Kiev, demonstrated the application of Blitzkrieg tactics on the Eastern Front. Von Manstein emphasized the importance of fluid battlefield control, rapid advances, and encirclement to disrupt and destroy Soviet forces.
One of the most notable accomplishments of Von Manstein’s career was the relief of the German 6th Army at Stalingrad between December 1942 and January 43. Von Manstein’s skillful management of limited resources and his use of mobile counterattacks nearly turned the tide of the battle. Though ultimately unsuccessful, the operation showcased his tactical
Skills and his ability to adapt Blitzkrieg principles to different situations. In the most successful German counteroffensive of the war, his troops regained control over Kharkov in February 1943. Following this victory, his forces were forced into retreat. Despite his frequent clashes with Adolf Hitler on strategy for the Eastern Front, Von Manstein
Remained steadfast in promoting a flexible, mobile approach to defence. He was willing to give up land with the aim of spreading Soviet forces thinly or provoking them to advance rapidly, creating an opportunity for German forces to counterattack and encircle them. However, Hitler disregarded Von Manstein’s counsel, keeping to his strategies of holding all
Positions firmly. Their disagreements escalated when Von Manstein publicly suggested Hitler should surrender control of the army to professional military strategists, proposing the inception of an Eastern commander-in-chief role. Hitler repeatedly dismissed this proposition, fearing it would undermine his control over Germany Von Von Manstein’s suggestion however raised concerns within Adolf Hitler’s closest allies
Like Hermann Göring, Joseph Goebbels, and SS Chief Heinrich Himmler, who were unwilling to relinquish any of their authority. Open doubts about Von Manstein’s loyalty began to arise, particularly from Heinrich Himmler, who suggested to Adolf Hitler that Von Manstein, being an idealist and
A defeatist, was ill-suited for troop command. Hitler’s patience ran thin with Von Manstein’s consistent objections, culminating in Hitler relieving Von Manstein of his command on March 31, 1944. Two days later, Hitler named Walther Model, a Hitler loyalist, as the new commander of Army
Group South, thus replacing Von Manstein. Despite this he was awarded the Swords for his Knight’s Cross, the third-highest German military honor, in recognition of his services to the Wehrmacht. Following a surgical procedure, Von Manstein spent his recovery period both at his residence
And a medical institution situated in Dresden. During the unsuccessful 20 July plot – an assassination attempt on Hitler that was part of an intended military coup d’état, Von Manstein was vacationing at a coastal resort on the Baltic. Despite having had
Interactions with three of the key plotters – Claus von Stauffenberg, Henning von Tresckow, and Rudolf Christoph Freiherr von Gersdorff, While Von Manstein did agree that change was necessary he refused to participate in the plot, as he still considered himself bound by duty. He maintained, “Preussische Feldmarschälle meutern
Nicht,” a statement indicating that Prussian field marshals do not partake in mutinies. His apprehension about a potential civil war also held him back. Though he didn’t actively participate in the conspiracy, he chose not to expose them. However, this did not prevent the Gestapo from monitoring Von Manstein’s house.
Realizing that Hitler had no intentions of assigning him a new role, Von Manstein acquired a property in East Pomerania in October 1944. However, his stay was cut short as he had to evacuate swiftly when the area was invaded by the Soviet forces. In the final weeks of January 1945,
Von Manstein ensured the safety of his family by moving them to the western parts of Germany. Eventually, he gave himself up to the British Field Marshal Montgomery, leading to his subsequent arrest by the British forces on August 23, 1945. As a high-ranking officer in the German military, his capture was significant,
And he was considered a valuable asset for gathering information about Nazi war efforts and operations. Von Manstein, like many other German military leaders, faced trial at the Nuremberg Trials. He was charged with war crimes and crimes against humanity due to his role in implementing brutal strategies during the war, including the Commissar Order,
Which directed the execution of Soviet political commissars. According to his testimony he received such order but refused to carry it out. During his trial, Von Manstein argued that he had merely followed orders and had not been directly involved in the atrocities committed
By Nazi forces. During the trials he, he was questioned about the concentration camps: “Did you at that time know anything about conditions in the concentration camps?” His response was: “No. I heard as little about that as the German people, or possibly even less, because when one
Was fighting 1,000 kilometers away from Germany, one naturally did not hear about such things.” His defense was not entirely successful, and he was found guilty of war crimes. Von Manstein was sentenced to 18 years in prison, but he was released in 1953 due to health concerns.
Following his release, he went on to counsel the West German government about the re-founding of its military force, the Bundeswehr. His war memoir, Verlorene Siege (Lost Victories), published in West Germany in 1955, became a best-selling sensation. It was critical of Hitler and his leadership approach. Despite its popularity,
Historians took issue with Von Manstein’s focus on the military aspects of the war, overlooking the political and moral implications. This selective focus was seen as an attempt to absolve himself and the high command from any accountability for the Holocaust. As time passed, Von Manstein became the subject of a “military cult”,
Lauded as not just one of Germany’s greatest generals, but one of the best in history. He was depicted as a military cult figure and leading personality, a general of almost mythical prowess, receiving immense public and scholarly recognition. Erich
Von Von Manstein passed away in Munich on the night of June 9, 1973, following a stroke. Well, that’s it for today’s video. We hope you like it. What do you think? Was Erich von Von Manstein Hitler’s greatest general? Leave your thoughts in the comments down below,
Also don’t forget to like, subscribe, and hit that notification bell for more History Inside video’s.
47 Comments
What do you think? Was Von Manstein Germany's greatest general? Leave your thoughts in the comments👇
Rather pathetic
A masterful mass murderer and a war criminal, Lucifer is extremely intelligent but doesn't mean a damm thing because he uses his intelligence to do more evil more harms more sinful deeds so it doesn't count as anything brave but rather as cowardly punkish jerks
Indelible surely, not inedible, mind you Hitler found his strategies hard to swallow at times.
Manstein was a exceptionaly capable strategist and military commander. If he wouldve been born in the US
or in Russia he would be a official national hero now for sure.
Who was the guy? Neve heard of him.
Von Manstein was one of the best strategist in WWII without doubt. The only problem was that von Manstein on the German side, and Zhukov and Vasilevsky on the Russian side, were not the deciding factors in Germany losing the war. Rather it was the huge landmass, resources, manpower and industrial capacity of the Soviet Union. Much like the current Russian-Ukrainian war, the outcome will be the same.
Different generals did specific things well. Give me Guderian to theorise, Rommel to attack, Kesselring to defend, Von Manstein to manage an entire front… Only one really understood war: Gerd von Rundstedt.
I'm surprised that Hitler didn't shoot him due to the size/shape of that honker!!
"An inedible mark.."😅
Well, he certainly thought so. lol
Had he been given freedom to use the resources available to him it would have been interesting to see how things developed on the Eastern Front and whether he would have had more success than Model who succeeded him?
Framing his failed Winter Storm offensive as an "achievement" was the last straw. Stopped watching afterwards.
Up to this point, you unquestioningly swallowed every syllable the guy wrote after the war to justify why the German Generals, allegedly the best generals in the world, who commanded the allegedly best soldiers in the world, lost the war.
Only the anti-Nazi Nazi's could consider anyone especially an extremely successful German general a "cult figure" but would never think that mass murderers like Genghis Khan or Alexander the Great could be war criminals.
His performance in charge of LVI Korps (mot.) in June/July 1941 was patchy: quick to seize the bridgehead over the Dvina in late June 1941, he allowed his subordinate commanders to waste effort at the Velikaya river by attacking into very unsuitable terrain; then not too long after, his aggressive blitzkrieg style almost lost him the 8th Pz division at Soltsy. After this setback though, it looks like he learned his lesson (how tough the Soviet troops could be at times) and I think his later generalship was amongst the best on the Eastern Front.
Wehraboo? Thereaboo!
Out of all the german generals only him can talk shit to hitler.. true story
Alla sua morte,nella metà degli anni '70,davanti alla sua casa di Amburgo sfilo' per rendere omaggio alla sua memoria, un reparto corazzato. La cosa suscitò polemiche ma fu doveroso omaggiare un grande soldato, uno tra i migliori Generali Tedeschi.
We studied German defense tactics to Russian breakthrough Ukraine needs war college training in other words to study manstein
Indelible, not inedible
Junto con Erwin Rommel y Almirante Karl Dönitz, fueron grandes innovadores y estrategas del Bando alemán, durante la Segunda Mundial, su mayor fracaso es haber servido a las Órdenes de Adolf Hitler sus círculo cercano Nazi.
En algunos caso se opusieron o contravinieron las órdenes, lo que les llevó a ser apartados menos en el caso del Almirante, y ejecutados como Rommel.
Si no hubieran servido al Ejercito Nazi, seguro que junto a Alemania hubieran cambiado la historia…
Un saludo y gracias por su trabajo.
🇪🇸👍👌 ✌️🕊️
so he did get to see America land on the moon.
When Germany fell, we all lost. Europe and America is now doomed and will soon face extermination to mass migration and race mixing propaganda.
great strategist, planner, not involved in politics. As the story is written by the winners, no surprise he was brought to stand trial❤
von Manstein was simply the best general of WW2. Not "german". He could do what was impossible… but he could not work fiction and even he made failures (like his misjudgment around kiew in late autum 1943).
But overall – he was "the man".
In pure defence General Heinrici was propably better, but if you need a guy who allows your troops to beat much stronger and better equipped enemy armies, your preference is von Manstein.
Guderian and manstien is a great general's but put on a wrong country 😢
🎧
I was laughing at ineatable
David Irving points out how Manstein and Hitler came up with the Ardennes move independently. Hitler heard of Manstein's view, which was being suppressed by higher ups, and took this as confirmation of the wisdom of the move, which was then adopted officially. So, Hitler should be credited too.
Model was superb on defense. He bled the Soviets. Manstein was a master of offense.
Robert E. Lee, of the South, was a master of both offense and defense. Had Lee commanded the numbers and resources Grant did, the struggle for Southern independence would have been hardly a struggle at all.
Manstein was the Chief of StaffofArmy Group South during the Polish campaign and not the commander of the 18. Panzerdivision! This division was formed in 1940.
Think, Manstein belongs to 10 greatest military leaders of mankind, in one row with Alexander, Napoleon, Dsengis, Julius Cäsar, Hannibal
When even Guderian said that Manstein was the best, then it is out of discussion.
The details about the positions and role of Mansteins during the war us wildly inacurate
i didnt realise von Manstein was edible
He may well have been the greatest, but he nevertheless turned out to be on the loosers' side, fortunately I say!
Von Manstein's last name would have been Clinton if Bill hadn't been too afraid of Hillary to divorce her and marry Monica.
A good Jew !!!
For me Manstein was Hitlers Greatest General and at that time he was his Geartest Enemy … For Manstein was a man that had INTELLECT for I seen that in many videos how he would set his WEB like a SPIDER and draw them into a SPIDERING END but have WE learn any thing from all these WARS from this time to NOW 2/3/2024 ??? RA 68 HELL FIRE
Interesting ❤
Second world war did not erupt.. it was began by germany!!!!!
A ruthless general and involved in scorched earth policy in USSR.
And all you hear from the west is their bragging up about going up against Rommel just to say "we also fought against a genius" Like if Rommel was the only great general the germans had to throw at them. Ahh propaganda and Hollywood. If only the allies faced Von Manstein with half the resources he used up against the soviets. Surely they would have received a big punch in the mouth. The overrated Patton or Monty for starters.
Fast Heinz !!!!
Enormously overrated. Once Stalin stopped meddling quite so much, both Malinovsky and Rokossovsky outgeneraled him. All the German commanders met their match on the Eastern front between 1942/3 to 1945.
Feldmarshall Erich von Manstein was really bester leader of Wehrmacht!
Yet Hitler fired him.
Same as the clown Zelensky fires his nazi generals today.
Yet Zelensky today knows nothing about war except to beg for weapons.
And fools like the Americans supply nazis too. Go figure.