How Important Is Personality on Football Manager??

Have you ever wondered if you should really pay that much attention to personality on Football Manager??? Well today we are testing just that! I simulate through the careers of twin wonderkids, one with the perfect personality and the other with the worst to determine how important personality is in the development of your players!

TWITCH: https://www.twitch.tv/matchday_meltdown

🔔: MAKE SURE YOU SUBSCRIBE & TURN NOTIFICATIONS ON

About Matchday Meltdown:
I am Matchday Meltdown, the home of Football Manager 2024 content. You can expect FM24 let’s play videos as well as a lot of yelling at anything and everything for the cycle of FM24. Make sure you hit the subscribe button and turn the notification bells on so you don’t miss anybody getting chewed out!

#FM24 #FootballManager2024 #FootballManager

Today I’m testing how important personality is for your Wonder Kids in football manager I’m doing this with twin Wonder Kids one being the nicest person to have ever lived so of course he’s going to be named Peter perfect the other one has been an absolute douchebag

Since before the womb so of course his name is Danny douchebag they both have 85 current ability and 185 potential ability and they both play as a striker the team that they’re starting at is St Orbin who are currently in the National League sah we’re going to S through

Their career and see if having a good personality is actually that beneficial for your players or Football manager or whether you can get away with having people with bad personalities let’s go and find out so as you can imagine Peter perfect has a 20 in all of the good

Personality attributes such as teamwork professionalism and loyalty and he has a one in the bad ones like controversy and dirtiness Danny douchebag on the other hand has it completely the other way with a 20 in dirtiness and controversy and a one in all the other important ones the visible attributes are really

Well rounded so that they can play in any position that they really wanted however Danny douchebag has a bit of a head start because his personality is so bad if I gave him the same stat as Peter perfect his current ability would be way less now that’s out the way let’s Sim

Through the first here and see how they got on okay now it’s been a year let’s go and have a look at how the boys went starting off with Danny douchebag so it looks like this season he played 23 League games scoring nine times and assisting six that’s very decent

Considering that he came off the bench 11 times it’s also interesting that he’s been trained to play out on the right wing I’m guessing that’s because they also wanted to play him and Peter perfect both in the starting 11 but looking at the tactics it seems that he

Played a majority of the games as the striker this year which makes me wonder where they played Peter perfect so let’s go and have a look okay and wow this did not take long at all Peter perfect has been picked up by Crystal Palace for a

Very cheap fee of 20,000 taking a look at how he went while he was at St Orbin it seems like he started every game that he played for them but bar one but he only scored seven times then after his move to Palace he played in the under

18s for the whole year only scoring two goals and they were both penalties unfortunately I can’t see what position he played for when he was at Crystal Palace under 18 however I’m guessing it’s as a right winger because when he was at St Obin he played as a striker

Every game and now he’s proficient at playing on the right wing speaking of St Alin they finished in fourth place this season hopefully Danny douchebag can get them promoted into the national league next season so let’s go and find out okay and doesn’t look like Danny douchebag got St Auburn’s promoted which

Is disappointing they finished fourth place again this year Danny’s had a much better year this time around however playing as a right winger for the whole season and he finished with 12 goals and 12 assists in 44 games averaging a 7.26 which is very good but some woring signs

Have started to show up about Danny douchebag some of his stats have actually started regressing but somehow his current ability is still now 91 so he hasn’t really improved that much but he still has improved it’s probably because he’s feel physicals have improved very slightly you would think

That this regression is because of his bad attitude and bad personality however St albin’s one and a halfar training facilities might also be hurting him as well teams are obviously putting the regression and attitude to the side as he’s currently wanted by sulfur in League 2 which is very promising Peter

On the other hand has stayed put in the Crystal Palace under 18s and he’s had some very nice improvements he now has a 123 current ability and he started to become a really really good player he’s had a very decent year as well scoring 30 goals and assisting 18 in 65 games

Hopefully he can crack into the first team next year so I’ll meet back with you guys after the third year okay and Peter perfect has done it he’s made it into the first team he made four starts and 17 appearances off the bench in the Premier League this season also

Collecting himself four goals and a very nice assist in the Premier League Palace also finished 12th this season and when he was on he played as a strike in every single game bar one moving over to Danny douchebag he made himself a move away from St Orbin this year and he now plays

For morham who are in League 2 the transfer Val was 43,000 and this year Danny has actually been very average he made 35 starts for morham in the league however he only scored two goals and no he hasn’t been playing a majority of games on the right wing he played the

Majority as a striker so maybe this level might just be too high for him after all his current ability is only 100 actually it was probably the fact that morhan finished in 21st Place missing out on relegation by goal difference that’s been the first 3 years

Let’s now have a look at the stats and compare the players and how they’ve gone as we can see Peter perfect is clearly the better player at this stage I’m now going to jump 5 years into their eighth season and hopefully by then both of them are playing for the national team

And both of them are playing in the Champions League also before we Sim if you really like this video and Football manager experiments please make sure to leave me a like subscribe and a comment down below it really helps the channel out and lets more people view these

Videos anyway let’s meet back in 5 years okay it’s been 8 years and we’re doing this one live now we’re going to start off with Danny douchebag and see how he’s done okay and interesting he has now moved to swansey for the last couple of years actually which is pretty

Interesting we can see that he played three years at morham and his transfer Fe actually went up to 300,000 in the end so I’m guessing they had a sell on fee but he did move from morom to Swansea for 7 million a couple seasons ago and he’s done all right for Swansea

His Seasons at morham though were okay he did get them promoted into League one though so that’s a decent accomplishment as of late he had probably his best season yet scoring six goals and seven assists and he averaged a 6.84 rating if we take a look at what position he

Actually played he did play half the season as a striker and half the season as a right winger if you have a look at his stats he has improved a bit but there are some stats that have fallen well and truly down the order like

Corners is now a five and his free kick taking is now a four in terms of him as a whole though he has never played for England he didn’t have any youth caps and he still hasn’t made a senior debut either for his team swany though they did actually get relegated this season

Which is so disappointing so they’re going back down into League one also a quick thing that you might have noticed is that his personality is now balanced and that is because his professionalism has gone up to a six I don’t know how that makes him balance but apparently it

Does let’s now go have a look at Peter perfect and see how he’s done if he’s moved on from Crystal Palace and he’s now playing for a Champions League team okay no it looks like Peter perfect is still playing for Crystal Palace he’s improved a heck of a lot with lots of

Green attributes in there and he scored 23 goals in the latest Premier League season taking a look at his career um yeah he’s had some really good seasons in here the last three seasons have been outstanding the most recent season was obviously his best but he’s improved

Ever since he broke into the first team last time we checked in since then his League appearances have just been going up and up and he’s been scoring more and more goals every year with never a downturn in his average rating in terms of his personality he’s now a

Charismatic leader which is awesome and he has played 34 games for England scoring 12 for Palace he has played every game as a striker and for England the same as well so he’s obviously now a striker however he can play as a cam and also a right winger you may have also

Seen that there is an active interest on him with the wanted sign and that is because man united want him maybe he’ll be going into the Champions League in the coming Seasons with a transfer value of 50 million to 150 million some clubs are going to have to Fork out a lot of

Money to pay for services ever moving back to Palace Peters actually guided them into 10th place this year which is a very decent effort and we can say that he actually won the Golden Boot for the Premier League which is another amazing achievement going to the golden brute

And he actually won it last season as well with 22 goals so that’s two years in a row that Peter perfix won the golden brute and these are some very promising signs his current ability is now 175 and that means that he’s only 10 away from reaching his full potential

And considering that he’s the key player for Palace and also the captain I wouldn’t be surprised if he gets snapped up really soon and and goes on to great things in Champions Leagues and things like that now we’ve seen the boys when they’re 23 let’s now Jump Ahead all the

Way to when they’re 30 to the end of their Prime and see how they’ve done all right we’ve gone another 7 years into the future and the boys are both 30 now and some really interesting things have happened starting off this time with Peter perfect and he now plays for Man

City he was sold there for 102 million after the very next season when we looked and since then he has been absolutely dominating for Manchester City his work season has been the most recent season where he’s only scored 10 goals but since then for every full season that he’s done he’s scored at

Least 15 goals in terms of his attributes he’s absolutely insane and he has reached his potential ability of 185 in terms of how he’s going for England he’s made 106 caps and scored 48 goals which is outstanding he’s now classed as a legendary Striker and also still a charismatic leader for this season

Though we can see that for England and also for Man City he played the majority of the year as a right winger coming to his milestones and he’s won the Premier League in his second season with Man City and since then he has been on absolute tear winning a second premier

League and then also becoming the ballondor runner up and that was to Evan Ferguson who won the ballondor for Liverpool a couple years later he actually came third in the balandor losing to a regen before winning it in the season that’s just gone in terms of other accomplishments he’s now won five

Premier Leagues and three Champions Leagues along with the club World Cup and he was also part of the England squad that did win the Euros in 2032 so so far it looks like having a really good personality is really beneficial let’s go and see how the worst personality ever Danny douchebag has

Gone on I’m tipping it’s nowhere near as good as Peter perfect and just by looking at his homepage we can see that he’s nowhere near as good as his brother his stats are really not that much better than when we last checked and he now plays for reading in his career he

Played four more games after we last checked in for swans then was bought by Bristol and while he was at Bristol he got them promoted into the Premier League and then was loaned out the season that they were in the Premier League and then bought by R for 18

Million if we have a look at his career as a whole though he’s a decent Championship level player but I understand why he’s never made it to the Premier League with a current ability of 115 it’s understandable that he never made it into the Top Flight for more

Than two games looking at him as a whole though he never made any caps for England and I’m tipping that he’s not going to make any in the future and in the most recent season he came off the bench pretty much every game and he scored six goals in terms of where

Reading played him majority of the time it was as a right winger and he did play five games at strik as scoring five goals so maybe they should play him there more often but overall for Danny douchebag it’s gone how you would kind of expect he really wasn’t driven and he

Just obviously has too much controversy to make it up any better and become a better player now we’ve done that let’s move to the end of their careers and by then hopefully Danny douchebags made it into the Premier League but I’m not holding my breath and hopefully Peter

Perfect has won the Euros a couple more times won a World Cup with England and won Hees Champions Leagues and Premier Leagues I’ll see you guys then okay this did not take long at all um D do bag has retired after the very next season so pretty disappointing unfortunately I

Couldn’t catch him right before he retired but he obviously didn’t play too many more games and wasn’t offered another contract so looks like his career is over and I would say that it’s pretty definitive that he was nowhere near as good as Peter perfect obviously his personality meant that he just

Didn’t want to play football anymore and so he’s packed the boots in and he’s not even going to be a staff member now Dan douchebag’s career is finished let’s go to the end of Peter perfects and I’ll meet back with you guys then all right

Peter Peri is retiring at the age of 36 in the year 2044 it’s been a very good career let’s go dive into what he did since we last checked in okay so it looks like he never moved away from Man City he played the rest of his career

There and was pretty dominant the whole way through the last season that just finished he only made six starts for the team and I guess that was his calling to go yep I’m packing it in in terms of personal achievements he did win another Bal Andor and that was in the year 2039

2040 so that’s really impressive and it looks like Peter perfect was All That Man City needed because after he joined they ended up going to win eight Champions Leagues and in terms of Premier Leagues Peter perfect won it nine times uh he joined in this year

2032 33 when they won it and they won it nine times since then I’m just going to leave this page on for a few seconds and you can read through that if you really want to in terms of his career though he is an outstanding player he ended with

175 caps for England and 79 goals and he really has just been Peter perfect speaking of England though the only other major tournament that he made it into a final was the World Cup in 2038 where they came Runners up but overall I think this experiment has clearly showed

Us that personality in your Wonder Kids is extremely important so if you’re going to pick up a Wonder kid who’s got a Fickle or a bad personality I would h on the side of caution and if you see a kid with moral citizen or anything like that absolutely spend as much money as

You can on them because well it’s clear the proof is in the pudding Peter Peri has had a way better career than Danny douchebag and it looks like Peter perfect reachs his potential ability way easier and way faster as opposed to Danny douchebag who didn’t even get

Close so obviously the personality has a lot to do with the way that they train and the way that they develop anyway I’d just like to say thank you guys so much for watching if you’ve made it this far in the video I love you um if you could

Just leave a like comment and subscribe that will mean the world to me and if you like these kind of experiments maybe check out this video here it’s a pretty good one and I also have this one here for you as well so make sure you like

Comment subscribe guys thank you so much and I’ll see you guys in the next one